So, I like the Shorty screen quite a lot. I also was sent the CalSci Large screen, and I get the desire for extensive coverage. Probably if I lived in a really cold climate, I’d love this screen. It provides a very large pocket of still (ish) air with amazingly little turbulence. But it’s so tall that I’m looking through or below the top edge, which is a deal killer for me; and I totally admit that this is one of my personal quirks. If you’re accustomed to looking through glass, you’ll love the taller screen for its tremendous coverage.